MTPM Notes: nuovo articolo 22/11/2026
There are performances that impress us with their perfection, others with their intelligence, control, or interpretive depth. And then there are a few, far rarer, in which after only a few minutes we almost forget that we are evaluating a pianist at all. We are simply watching someone who is happy to be making music.
That is the feeling I get from these recordings of Erroll Garner, made by the BBC in London around 1964 and collected in Erroll Garner – In Performance. On the cover appears a line attributed to Newsweek: “The man for whom the piano was invented.” It might sound like one of those promotional exaggerations designed to glorify an artist, but after listening to Garner for a few minutes, the phrase somehow begins to seem rather less exaggerated.
Garner is heard here at the height of his artistic maturity, together with Eddie Calhoun on bass and Kelly Martin on drums, and what strikes us immediately is not one particular pianistic quality, but the sense that everything happens effortlessly. The swing, the harmonic imagination, the dialogue with the other musicians, the rhythmic displacements, the sudden detours, even the way he accompanies what he is playing with his body, his smile, and those vocal sounds that seem constantly to anticipate or chase the phrases coming from the piano. There seems to be no distance between the idea and the gesture. The music seems to come toward him.
Perhaps this is what moves me most. Garner does not seem to sit at the piano in order to prove anything. He does not appear interested in showing us how good he is, how much he knows about harmony, or how refined his rhythmic sense may be. And yet all of those things are constantly before us. His technique is immense, but never demands attention; his harmonic knowledge is extraordinarily sophisticated, yet never becomes an intellectual exercise; his rhythmic control is astonishing, but produces freedom rather than rigidity. Everything seems directed toward something infinitely simpler: playing. And enjoying himself while doing it.
It is striking how rare this quality can be, even among great performers. At times we can feel the weight of study, responsibility, tradition, career, expectation. In Garner, by contrast, there seems to be something elemental: the same sense of wonder as someone discovering that pressing a key produces a sound and immediately wanting to know what the next one will be. Except that behind that wonder lie decades of absorbed music, listening, experience, and a deeply physical relationship with the instrument.
And then there is the swing. Simply calling it extraordinary is not enough, because what is most surprising is how contemporary it still feels today. Martha Glaser, who accompanied Garner’s career for many years and wrote the notes for this edition, emphasizes the immediacy of these images and the strikingly modern quality of his playing. She is right: there is almost none of the historical distance we normally feel when listening to a document from the 1960s.
The left hand can establish a pulse of extraordinary solidity, almost orchestral in character, while the right seems to inhabit a different dimension of time. It anticipates, delays, settles onto the beat and then immediately moves away from it, yet everything remains perfectly balanced. Garner seems able to shift time without ever losing it. This is probably one of the reasons he is so difficult to imitate. His outward gestures, certain formulas and accents can be reproduced, but his swing is not a formula: it is a way of feeling time. There is no metronome on one side and freedom on the other. Freedom grows precisely out of the solidity of the inner pulse.
Then come the chords, and sometimes one could stop right there. A single Garner voicing can contain more musical information than pages of theory: the distribution of voices, registers, inner notes, tensions, dynamics, and the relationship with the melody. There are chords that somehow feel full and transparent at the same time, massive without becoming heavy, sophisticated without ever sounding contrived. Above all, they possess a quality that is extremely difficult to teach: they seem inevitable. It is exactly that chord, at exactly that moment.
The paradox is that behind such spontaneity lies enormous expertise. Garner was largely self-taught and had played by ear since childhood, but to describe him simply as instinctive would be profoundly reductive. The instinct of a great musician is not the absence of knowledge. It is knowledge that has become so deeply absorbed that it no longer needs to be called by name.
Garner’s celebrated introductions are another small wonder. He can begin playing and leave us for minutes with no obvious clue as to which tune is about to emerge. He changes key, atmosphere, register, harmony, building what seems like an independent miniature narrative, until suddenly a familiar melody appears. At that moment, everything that came before seems to acquire meaning retrospectively. It is natural to wonder how much had been planned in advance and how much was genuinely being invented in that instant, but perhaps the question itself is wrong. In musicians of this calibre, preparation and improvisation are no longer two clearly separate categories. There is an absorbed vocabulary, certainly, but it is constantly recombined by the present moment. Garner does not seem to perform an introduction: he seems to discover it as he plays.
In the notes accompanying the DVD, there is a particularly effective expression: Garner is shown in the very act of creation. That is precisely what makes these images so precious. We do not merely witness the result; we witness the process. We see Garner reacting to the bass, to the drums, to one of his own previous ideas. One phrase provokes the next, an accent opens a possibility, a melodic fragment suggests a detour that perhaps did not exist a second earlier. Martha Glaser also describes the almost audio vérité character of these recordings, and the phrase is revealing because the performance is neither sterilized nor polished smooth. We see his physical energy, we feel the trio breathing, and even the close-ups of his hands become illuminating: they show how deeply Garner’s sound is connected not only to the notes themselves, but to the physical way in which he takes possession of the keyboard.
Perhaps these recordings affect us even more strongly today because we live in an age in which almost everything can be corrected. We can record a hundred takes, edit, replace, align, choose the best version, even manufacture an artificial impression of spontaneity. Here, by contrast, we can still feel something that no amount of editing can truly create: the risk of the moment. The risk that an idea may not work, the risk of choosing a direction without knowing exactly where it will lead. Garner, however, seems to possess a quality even more valuable than the ability to avoid mistakes: he seems capable of transforming whatever happens into musical material. Perhaps that is what true freedom is. Not being able to do anything at all, but being able to give musical meaning to whatever happens.
A small anecdote told by Glaser also captures something essential about his personality. After one number, BBC presenter Steve Race asked Garner whether he would play anything else. Garner, never particularly fond of stage speeches, simply replied, “That’s all.” Race took this as the title of the well-known standard That’s All and announced that Garner was about to play it, when Garner had actually meant that he was finished. It is an almost perfect misunderstanding for him, because it operates according to the same mechanism as his music: a phrase suddenly moves in a direction no one expected. And even endings, with Garner, seem to have trouble becoming endings at all.
Watching this concert leaves me with one question above all: why do we practise? It may sound naïve, especially for anyone who has devoted a lifetime to an instrument. We practise in order to gain control, to understand, to avoid mistakes, to face ever greater difficulties. All of that is true. But perhaps there is another level beyond it: to practise so much that we can finally stop thinking about practice while we are playing. To know the instrument so deeply that we can still be surprised by what comes out of our own hands. To prepare so thoroughly that we can afford the unexpected.
Garner’s freedom does not come from a lack of discipline. It comes from a discipline that has become invisible. And this is probably what makes these images almost moving. For a few minutes, as we watch him, the profession, the career, the market, success, criticism, competition, even the very idea of performance all seem to disappear. What remains is a man at a piano, a chord that produces a smile, that smile generating a phrase, the phrase suggesting another, the bass responding, the drums entering. And suddenly three people are building something that did not exist a moment earlier.
Perhaps we have invented many complicated words to describe all of this: swing, voicing, timing, improvisation, interplay. Garner seems to remind us that, before all those words, there was a much simpler one: play.
And perhaps part of our work as musicians consists precisely in taking a very long journey in order, one day, to find our way back there.