MTPM Notes: nuovo articolo 22/11/2026
The gradual erosion of music’s economic and cultural value is one of the most striking contradictions of our time. Never before have we had access to such an extraordinary amount of musical content, yet rarely have we given so little thought to the work required to create it. Music accompanies virtually every moment of our day, fills commercial spaces, supports advertising, fuels digital platforms, and contributes to the identity of millions of people. But when it comes to financially compensating those who create, perform, or record it, music suddenly seems to become something that should be available for free. This contradiction affects society as a whole and should prompt everyone working in the industry to reflect deeply, preferably without nostalgia, prejudice, or claims of superiority.
Yet within the music world, a tendency persists that I find particularly troubling: the inclination to divide artistic production into a narrow realm of supposed excellence and a vast, undifferentiated landscape of mediocrity, where musicians, engineers, producers, small record labels, and recording studios are relegated simply because they do not belong to certain professional circles. The dividing line is often drawn using seemingly objective criteria, such as the prestige of recording facilities, the cost of equipment, the reputation of particular brands, or the prominence of record releases. These factors can certainly contribute to the final result, but they cannot automatically certify artistic merit, much less justify dismissing everything outside those circles as a manifestation of incompetence.
The point is not to deny the difference between work carried out with expertise and work approached carelessly. Technical knowledge matters, professional experience counts, and the choice of equipment can significantly affect the outcome. But recognizing these differences is one thing; turning them into a hierarchy in which those who possess certain resources or belong to a particular environment consider themselves the guardians of unquestionable truth, while everyone else is dismissed as an amateur, is quite another. Professional authority should emerge from what one accomplishes and from the ability to support one’s judgments with sound reasoning, not from a persistent need to diminish the work of others.
This kind of condescension strikes me most when it is directed at people who are simply trying to continue making music. It is easy to demand the highest production standards, prestigious recording studios, sophisticated equipment, and highly specialized professionals. It is considerably harder to explain how all of this can be financially sustained in a market where physical media sales have declined dramatically, streaming often provides inadequate compensation for artists with smaller audiences, and a substantial portion of the public now considers free access to music perfectly normal. We continue to demand results comparable to the great record productions of the past, forgetting that those recordings were supported by entirely different economic structures, investments, and commercial prospects.
A musician who wants to record an album today faces circumstances that those who established their careers in earlier decades may never have experienced in quite the same way. Major labels select a limited number of projects, independent productions require personal investment, and the possibility of recovering expenses through sales is often extremely limited. Added to this are the costs of instruments, maintenance, travel, venues, rehearsals, and promotion. Faced with such circumstances, what exactly is the solution supposed to be? Give up recording because one cannot afford the most prestigious facilities? Wait indefinitely for someone to invest in a project? Or find financially sustainable production methods while taking responsibility for one’s choices?
The expansion of home recording studios and small independent operations has certainly brought with it widely varying levels of professional expertise. Access to affordable technology does not automatically turn someone into an audio engineer, any more than owning a piano makes someone a pianist. Recording well requires knowledge of acoustics, critical listening skills, experience with microphone placement, and an understanding of the relationship between sound sources and their acoustic environment. Nevertheless, dismissing the entire home studio phenomenon as a degradation of the profession ignores how much technological democratization has expanded opportunities for music production and distribution. A room does not become a professional recording studio simply because someone installs a computer and a pair of monitors, but neither does an expensive studio automatically guarantee competence or musical sensitivity.
The same applies to playback equipment. Studio monitors must meet specific requirements regarding frequency response, reliability, dynamic capability, and adaptability to the listening environment. Certain professional products offer performance that less expensive alternatives may struggle to match, particularly in acoustically controlled settings. But reducing the entire field to a handful of brands while treating everything else as unworthy of consideration turns a technical assessment into a question of belonging to an exclusive club. A piece of equipment should be evaluated according to how it actually performs in its intended environment, not merely by the prestige of its manufacturer.
Judgments about contemporary recordings also call for greater balance. Excessive dynamic compression, the relentless pursuit of perceived loudness, and mastering practices designed primarily for immediate impact are real phenomena that can compromise the natural character of sound. But they do not justify dismissing most contemporary productions as mediocre, nor do they warrant confusing the technical characteristics of a recording with its artistic value. A technically flawless recording can capture a musically insignificant performance, while an imperfect recording can preserve an extraordinary musical experience. The history of recorded music offers countless examples.
Likewise, listening through inexpensive headphones, smartphones, or small speakers does not necessarily represent a form of cultural impoverishment. An accurate playback system can reproduce tonal, spatial, and dynamic information that other devices cannot, but the musical experience is not defined solely by the quality of the equipment being used. A young person discovering Beethoven through smartphone earbuds is not necessarily having a culturally inferior experience to an audiophile listening to a recording through an enormously expensive sound system. The latter may hear sonic details that escape the former, but that does not necessarily mean a deeper understanding of the music itself. Musical culture should broaden access to art, not turn it into an economic privilege.
Particularly questionable is the ease with which performers who work with small labels or choose to produce their own recordings are judged. The fact that a musician has not secured a place in the catalog of a major record label does not demonstrate artistic mediocrity. Editorial decisions depend on artistic considerations, but also on commercial strategies, investment priorities, name recognition, professional relationships, and sales projections. Treating inclusion on a major label as proof of artistic merit, and exclusion from that system as evidence of inadequacy, means granting the market an artistic authority that, in other respects, one might rightly challenge.
This is precisely the contradiction I find most revealing. On the one hand, the market is accused of sacrificing music to commercial interests; on the other, the prestige of major labels and their selection processes are treated as virtually unquestionable guarantees of artistic worth. But if the market is truly so heavily influenced by considerations unrelated to art, why should we regard its hierarchies as infallible? And if the value of a performance does not coincide with commercial success, why should we assume that a musician excluded from prestigious circles has nothing meaningful to communicate?
I know the level of preparation required for a pianist to pursue an artistic career seriously. I know how much study, discipline, and self-criticism are necessary to develop a convincing interpretation, and I have no intention of suggesting that every recording project automatically deserves to be undertaken. Some productions are unnecessary, some performances are insufficiently mature, and some initiatives place promotion ahead of musical substance. But judgments should arise from examining the work itself, not from the position occupied by the person who created it. An independent recording can document neglected repertoire, champion contemporary composers, provide opportunities for young performers, and preserve artistic experiences that might otherwise remain unknown. The ability to release a recording does not certify its value, but neither does the absence of a major label make it worthless.
The central issue, however, remains both economic and cultural. If music is perceived as something that should cost nothing, sustaining the professions involved in creating it inevitably becomes increasingly difficult. An experienced audio engineer deserves appropriate compensation, just as musicians, composers, piano technicians, producers, and every other professional involved in the creative process do. But this problem cannot be solved by criticizing people with limited resources for being unable to afford the most expensive services. That would be like blaming a young pianist for not owning a concert grand piano, forgetting that more modest instruments may provide the very foundation on which a future career is built.
When professional services become financially inaccessible to a growing number of musicians, we should examine the circumstances that have brought us to this point: the responsibilities of digital platforms, the role of cultural institutions, and our collective inability to assign meaningful economic value to artistic creation. The crisis did not begin because someone bought an inexpensive microphone or decided to record in a room at home. Those decisions are often consequences of a much deeper transformation.
In this environment, asking musicians to reject every form of adaptation risks condemning them to invisibility. Anyone pursuing a musical career today must possess solid artistic skills, but is also frequently expected to understand communication, organization, production, and distribution—areas that, until a few decades ago, were largely handled by separate professionals. This is not necessarily progress, and it certainly risks diverting time and energy away from practice and artistic exploration. But it is a reality we must confront, not a moral failing to be condemned.
One final consideration strikes me as perhaps the most important. If we are genuinely concerned about the future of music, we should ask ourselves what we are personally doing to develop an audience capable of listening to it, understanding it, and supporting it. Criticizing the superficiality of contemporary consumption may be legitimate, but describing the public as a culturally impoverished mass risks turning an educational challenge into a form of social contempt. People are not born knowing how to recognize the complexity of an interpretation or distinguish an ordinary performance from an extraordinary one. These abilities develop through experience, encounters, education, and curiosity. If we want audiences to become more discerning listeners, we must provide opportunities for them to do so, rather than demanding that they already possess the knowledge required to enter our world.
Classical music, in particular, cannot afford to turn its tradition into a fortress from which everything outside is viewed with condescension. Its extraordinary richness deserves to be discovered by a much broader audience than the one that regularly attends concert halls. But such openness requires a willingness to engage, an ability to communicate, and a certain humility in recognizing that the value of a musical experience does not depend exclusively on the cultural codes through which we are accustomed to interpreting it. Defending great music does not necessarily mean defending the social and professional conventions that have governed its dissemination for decades.
As a musician, I continue to regard rigorous study, technical preparation, and interpretive responsibility as essential. I believe recordings should be made with the greatest possible care and that every artistic project deserves serious reflection on its purpose. But I do not believe these convictions entitle anyone to belittle those who work under different circumstances. Experience should make us more aware of the complexity of our profession and the challenges it presents, not encourage the belief that we belong to a privileged class entitled to judge everyone else.
The greatest risk is not that there are too many musicians, too many recordings, or too many small production companies today. It is that, in a society where music is constantly consumed but increasingly undervalued as professional work, only those who already possess sufficient financial resources will be able to pursue it as a career. That would amount to a selection process based not on talent, preparation, or artistic depth, but on the financial ability to sustain an activity that the market no longer compensates adequately.
The question we should be asking, then, is not whether today’s musical world lives up to our ideals, but how much we are willing to do to ensure those ideals remain realistically attainable. A culture that demands extraordinary results without addressing the conditions necessary to achieve them risks turning art into a privilege reserved for a few and the defense of tradition into a form of exclusion.
Music does not need someone standing above everyone else, deciding who deserves to exist. It needs a society that recognizes the value of those who create it, perform it, teach it, and strive to keep it alive, even through imperfect paths.
And perhaps we should remember that the real problem is not independent production, home recording studios, or unknown musicians. It is indifference. The very indifference we risk encouraging whenever, instead of building a future for music, we choose to explain how little everything that does not resemble our past is worth.