MTPM Notes: nuovo articolo 22/11/2026
I recently read a reflection on Facebook by Filippo Michelangeli, a journalist, publisher, and editor of Amadeus and Suonare news, a highly respected professional with a deep understanding of the classical music world and its inner workings. His post, titled “Neither Rising Stars nor Living Legends,” addresses an issue that is both obvious and rarely discussed: the gradual marginalization of performers between the ages of forty and sixty, too old to be considered promising young talents, yet not old or famous enough to be celebrated as legends. Michelangeli rightly observes that it is precisely during these years that many musicians achieve an ideal balance of technical mastery, experience, and interpretive depth.
His words prompted me to put into writing thoughts I have carried with me for years, thoughts that many of my colleagues probably share but are reluctant to express publicly. In our profession, certain things are whispered in hallways, confided to friends, or bitterly discussed after concerts, but rarely stated openly and without mincing words. The risk of jeopardizing relationships, opportunities, and professional connections is always lurking. Frankly, I believe it is time to speak up.
In the world of classical music, what matters far too often is not how good you are, but how convenient you are.
Young talents are ideal for the system. They have ambitions, expectations, and a desperate need for opportunities. They can be paid very little, sometimes nothing at all, while being persuaded that exposure is already a form of compensation and that they should consider themselves lucky simply to have been invited. Their willingness is exploited even as they are publicly celebrated as the great performers of tomorrow. It is the perfect combination: enthusiasm, talent, and low costs. Of course, there are serious presenters who genuinely invest in young musicians, but it would be naive to pretend that this is the only reality. Far too often, behind the rhetoric of nurturing talent lies nothing more than an opportunity to save money on performers' fees.
At the opposite end of the spectrum are the established names, those who continue to dominate concert programs thanks to reputations built over decades. Some remain extraordinary artists; others are well past their prime. But that hardly matters: a famous name sells tickets, prestige provides reassurance, and nobody has much interest in questioning a legend, even when the actual performance would suggest a more critical assessment. As a result, audiences sometimes applaud a career rather than a performance, pretending not to hear shortcomings that would be judged mercilessly in any other musician. Respect for a great artistic legacy is entirely justified, but it should not become permanent immunity from musical criticism.
And then there are people like us, caught somewhere in the middle. I am almost 47 years old, with an international concert career behind me, competition victories, years of experience, and an artistic identity of my own. I continue to practice, perform, teach, and challenge myself, with an interpretive awareness I simply could not have possessed twenty years ago. I am no longer a young prospect who can be exploited for next to nothing, nor am I a legend whose name can be used as a selling point. Above all, I know the value of my work. I no longer feel the need to accept just any conditions simply to add another concert date to my résumé or to be told that I should be grateful for the opportunity.
And here lies the paradox: just when a musician may be entering the most artistically rewarding phase of their career, they risk becoming less commercially attractive. They no longer offer the excitement of a new discovery, yet they may not have a name that sells tickets on its own. They have experience, expertise, personality, and something meaningful to say, but all these qualities seem to matter less than how easily they can be marketed and fitted into a concert season.
Naturally, nobody is entitled to a place onstage simply because of their résumé, the competitions they have won, or the number of years they have spent performing. I do not claim that privilege for myself, nor would I grant it to anyone else. But neither should someone receive preferential treatment simply for being twenty or eighty years old. A performer's worth should be judged by how they play today, not by the promise of their future or the glory of their past.
But there is an even more convenient way to avoid making that judgment: simply don't invite them at all.
Because if you never hear them, you never have to acknowledge their worth. If you deny them a platform, it is as though they do not exist artistically. And if they do not exist, they cannot challenge your decisions. It is an almost ingenious mechanism in its perversity: you do not have to prove that someone does not deserve to perform; you merely have to make sure they never get the chance to prove otherwise. And you can go on believing you were right, without ever running the risk of being contradicted by the facts.
This is what I personally find most infuriating. Not the absence of an invitation, which nobody has the right to demand, but the ease with which the system can overlook an artist without ever taking responsibility for genuinely evaluating them. Because truly listening requires expertise, curiosity, and independent judgment. It also means accepting the possibility that a performer who has been overlooked for years might actually play better than someone who appears regularly on concert programs. It is much easier to rely on management agencies, trends, established professional relationships, and familiar, marketable names. The choices become predictable, nobody takes any risks, and the system continues to perpetuate itself.
I am not suggesting that every musician of my generation is outstanding, that young performers are necessarily immature, or that older artists are artistically exhausted. That would be absurd. What I am challenging is precisely the habit of replacing musical judgment with criteria that have little or nothing to do with music. If a young musician plays magnificently, they deserve to be heard and paid fairly. If a great master has retained their artistic stature, they deserve every recognition. And if a fifty-year-old performer has something important to communicate, they should have the opportunity to do so without being penalized simply because they are no longer a novelty.
Michelangeli's post deserves credit for drawing attention to this overlooked generation. I would go a step further: I do not believe this is always a matter of mere oversight. In many cases, it seems to me to be the result of a system that has learned to favor whatever is financially convenient, marketable, or professionally reassuring, while pushing aside anything that would require a genuine artistic assessment.
So by all means, let's keep talking about meritocracy, excellence, and supporting artists. They are beautiful words, especially when they come with absolutely no obligation to live up to them.
After all, the system doesn't need to prove that you're not good enough. It only needs to make sure nobody ever gets the chance to discover that you are.