MTPM Notes: nuovo articolo 22/11/2026
There's something profoundly ridiculous about today's classical music world: the relentless need to prove just how talented, important, sought-after, and preferably indispensable everyone is. It's a gigantic circus of self-promotion, where every concert is a triumph, every recording is an unmissable event, every review is extraordinary, every debut is historic, every collaboration is prestigious, and every performer is exceptional. Is everything really so goddamn extraordinary? Is there no such thing anymore as a concert that's simply good, a recording that's interesting but debatable, or a performance that succeeds only in part? Has the language of music become so thoroughly contaminated by advertising that it's practically impossible to tell an honest opinion from a shameless promotional plug?
People congratulate each other publicly, celebrate one another, and hand out compliments with suspicious generosity. Everyone's a genius, everyone's a towering artist, everyone's an indispensable interpreter. And you can't help wondering whether the real objective is often not to express a genuine opinion, but to get noticed by the right person, strengthen a useful connection, or secure a place in the inner circle. It's a massive festival of mutual self-congratulation, where everyone applauds everyone else and almost nobody seems willing to say what they actually think. Naturally, God forbid you express reservations about an established artist. If you're not impressed, you're the problem. If you question an interpretive choice, you obviously didn't understand it. If you dare challenge a performance that everyone else has praised, you're immediately labeled jealous. Because in the classical music world, jealousy has become the universal explanation for any criticism—a wonderfully convenient way to avoid discussing the actual merits.
Meanwhile, a musician's worth seems to depend less and less on what they express through their art and more and more on whom they know, who represents them, where they perform, and how marketable they are. A powerful agent, a prestigious concert series, or a famous hall becomes an implicit certificate of artistic superiority. As though a pianist suddenly became a better musician the moment someone decided to invest in their career. And what about those who haven't had the luck, the connections, or the desire to enter those circles? Are they supposed to feel like worthless pieces of shit? Should they consider their entire musical lives failures because they never found someone willing to promote them, never cultivated the right connections, or never spent their lives building relationships designed to advance their careers?
Who the fuck decided that the market gets to determine an artist's worth?
I'm not denying that a career requires talent, determination, initiative, and the ability to create opportunities. Nor do I consider those who have achieved success any less authentic. There are extraordinary musicians who fully deserve the recognition they've received. But turning that recognition into an absolute ranking of artistic worth is complete bullshit. Professional success is an achievement, not a final verdict on the quality of those who attain it—or those who don't.
Unfortunately, this mentality has also found its way into music education. A teacher is no longer simply someone you learn from; they're expected to be an investment. They need to know the right people, recommend students for competitions, introduce them to artistic directors, and get them booked in concert series. Ideally, they should be able to open doors. And if they can't open doors, what good are they? It's a question that, even when left unspoken, seems to hang increasingly over relationships between students and teachers. Of course, this doesn't apply to everyone, but it's a troubling trend, one that reduces musical education to a glorified job-placement agency.
And let's stop beating around the bush: the music teacher has become the music world's whore. A student shows up, introduces themselves, expresses enthusiasm, professes admiration, makes use of the teacher's expertise for a few weeks or months, and then, once they've gotten what they came for, casually moves on to the next one. Another teacher, another masterclass, another name to add to the résumé—preferably someone with more influential connections and more promising doors to open. The educational relationship becomes a pay-as-you-go service. You take what you need, pay the fee, say thank you, and move on. No genuine interest in building a lasting relationship, no particular appreciation for the work involved, and no awareness that a teacher isn't a vending machine dispensing instant pianistic solutions.
And let's be clear: students have every right to change teachers, explore different artistic perspectives, and look elsewhere for something they're not finding. The problem isn't changing teachers; it's treating every human and professional relationship exclusively in terms of its immediate usefulness. What's particularly grotesque is that this behavior is often presented as a sign of maturity and initiative. You're supposed to gain experience, meet big names, collect advice, attend masterclasses, and build connections. Fine. But when you keep moving from one teacher to another, taking a little from each without giving anyone enough time to build something meaningful, you risk accumulating instructions without ever developing a genuine musical identity. You collect teachers like trading cards, only to discover that having studied with ten famous pianists doesn't necessarily mean you understand music any better.
Meanwhile, the teacher is expected to remain endlessly available, enthusiastic, understanding, and preferably flattered to have been chosen—even if only for the time it takes the student to realize that this particular teacher doesn't have the right connections. Because ultimately, as long as you're useful, you're a master; once you're no longer useful, you're just the previous name on the list. And perhaps not even that, if you're not prestigious enough to deserve a line on the résumé.
I don't have doors to sell. I don't promise careers, guarantee prizes, or keep a list of influential people I can call to arrange someone's professional future. What I can offer is my experience, my knowledge, my ability to listen, and my capacity to work seriously on an interpretation. I can spend hours discussing phrasing, tonal color, the meaning of a pause, or the need to completely rethink a musical passage. I can teach what I've learned over a lifetime devoted to the piano. But I cannot guarantee that any of this will lead to success. And more importantly, I have no intention of pretending that I can.
If what you're looking for is a backstage pass into the right professional circles, I'm probably not the person for you. But if a teacher's worth is to be measured primarily by the number of career opportunities they can provide, then we've completely lost sight of what teaching is supposed to mean.
And frankly, I couldn't give a damn about having to prove to anyone that my musical life has meant something.
I don't have to justify it to an agent who never represented me, an artistic director who never invited me, or a colleague who has performed in more prestigious halls than I have. I'm perfectly aware that I could have made different choices, invested more in promoting myself, pursued other opportunities, and cultivated different relationships. Not everything that failed to happen can be blamed on the system, and it would be childish to claim otherwise. But acknowledging my own responsibility is one thing; accepting that the market has the right to determine our worth is quite another. And that's a right I refuse to grant it.
Because devoting your life to music should have a meaning that survives even the possibility of never receiving the recognition you hoped for. Otherwise, we're no longer searching for something through art. We're simply chasing other people's approval, hoping that sooner or later someone will finally give us permission to consider ourselves good enough.
I'll continue to admire great pianists when their playing deserves it, respect those who have built extraordinary careers, study, teach, record, and search for the very things in music that made me devote my life to it in the first place. But I refuse to consider someone artistically superior simply because their name appears on a more prestigious concert poster than mine. I don't need to invent some sense of moral superiority to compensate for what I haven't achieved. Nor am I going to pretend that recognition doesn't feel good. But there's an enormous difference between wanting recognition and spending your entire life chasing it at the expense of everything else.
So go ahead. Keep tearing each other apart over contracts, agencies, festivals, reviews, likes, and views. Keep celebrating everything you do as an earth-shattering event and measuring your importance by the prestige of the people who invite you. That's your choice, and you have every right to make it. But don't expect everyone else to enter the same race, and don't assume that those who choose not to participate are somehow worth less.
I may not have become the pianist the market wanted to sell. But that doesn't give the market the right to decide what kind of pianist I am.
Go ahead and tear each other apart, if you really can't help yourselves.
In the meantime, I'd rather focus on music.